How are you managing your portfolio now? SGXcafe will do it for you intelligently.
Sign up for free now!

Subscribe to RSS feed How Much is a Stock Worth?

By evankoh posted on 17 Aug 2015  -  4,187 views

Recently, I read a book, A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton G. Malkiel. In the book, he discussed two ways to valuate a stock - The firm-foundation theory and the castle-in-the-air theory.

The firm-foundation theory assumes that each stock has a true value which is equal to the present value of all its future dividends. It is likely that you have heard something similar because this approach is somewhat similar to Warren Buffett's style of "buying securities whose prices are below the true value, and selling those with prices are above the true value".

Of course, the challenge is in determining the true value, which can be broken down into two parts.
1) Forecasting of future dividends of that stock, and
2) Estimating the (current and future) market interest rate.

The castle-in-the-air theory is also known as the "greater fool" theory. It does not matter how much you pay for any stock as long as you are able to find a "greater fool" who is willing to pay more for it. A story mentioned in the book is that stock investment is like entering a newspaper beauty-judging contest where one must vote for the prettiest face out of a hundred photos, and the prettiest face is determined by the largest number of votes. It is basically saying that the true value of a stock does not matter as much as its perceived value by investors.

The way I translate these two theories to practical strategies to support my stock-buying decisions is as follows:
1) I favor stocks that are likely to have good future dividends (I will forecast this using a simple approach until I find better and more reliable approaches).
2) I try to avoid being the "greater fool" by shunning all stocks with high P/E (using STI's P/E as a gauge).


sggamelover - We should always use The firm-foundation theory.
15 Jun 2016 09:03:17

Next Article > < Previous Article
How to retire? A Simple Trend Analysis of Dividends

List All Articles Other articles by evankoh

How "unlucky" can you get from investing?
Investing in the stock market is often deemed as risky and difficult by many. Here, I would show how a simple strategy would perform for a someone who does not know much about the stock market and is very unlucky when it comes to investing. Firstly, for someone without much knowledge in investing, index investing is ideal because it gives good diversification with just one stock. Also, rather than ...

Should You Avoid High P/E?
It has often been advocated to avoid any stocks with a high P/E. The common argument is that you would be overpaying for hype stocks. However, overpaying or not depends on how the high P/E stocks behaves in future. For example, if high P/E stocks actually do grow at a rate that is significantly higher than low P/E stocks, then it is arguably justifiable to buy stocks with a high P/E. One real-life ...

Analyze and Compare Stocks (using SGXcafe)
Analyze Every investor has his/her favorite set of metrics that they look at when performing stock analysis and valuation. Therefore, it is difficult to decide which metric to display in SGXcafe, hence most of the time, I simply choose to display information that I am personally interested in. But I want to make SGXcafe more customizable so that it can provide better value to everyone. Incidentally, ...